Skip to content

Shopping Cart

Your cart is currently empty.

Enable cookies to use the shopping cart

Special instructions for seller

Subtotal

$0.00 USD

Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout

Collection:

Search

We are located at 4212 South College Ave, #101, Fort Collins, CO (in the Hobby Lobby shopping center next to Peachy Nails)- come visit! Or give us a call at 720-229-6494

Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop

Home
Year Round Pies
Cakes, Tortes & Cheesecakes
Baked Goods
Cocoa Bombs
Cake Balls
Cupcakes
Easter
Mother’s Day
Teacher Appreciation
Graduation
Fall Seasonal Pies
Thanksgiving Goodies

Number of items in your cart: 0

Menu

Home
Year Round Pies
Cakes, Tortes & Cheesecakes
Baked Goods
Cocoa Bombs
Cake Balls
Cupcakes
Easter
Mother’s Day
Teacher Appreciation
Graduation
Fall Seasonal Pies
Thanksgiving Goodies
Log in

Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie

Regular price: $32.50 USD
Regular price
Sale price: $32.50 USD
Unit price: per

Error Quantity must be 1 or more

Lip-smackin' good Key Lime Pie - just try it!

Share on Facebook
Tweet on Twitter
Pin on Pinterest

Handmade Daily

Every day, made to order, just for you from recipes handed down from my Grandmother. I use only the best ingredients, local flours, farm fresh eggs, local fruits and produce to obtain the best baked goods possible.

Local Pickup

Our baked goods are available for pick up at 4212 South College #101, Fort Collins, CO 80525; (in the Hobby Lobby shopping center next to Peachy Nails) Hours are Monday-Saturday 9:00am-5:00pm and Sunday 9:00-3:00. Come see us!!! 720-229-6494

Newsletter

Email address

© 2025, Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop Powered by Shopify

Payment methods accepted

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.